← Back to Blog

Sharethrough’s Research Leads to Product that Improves Banner Performance

Research
2
minutes
Technical Level
February 9, 2022
2
minutes
February 9, 2022
Technical Level
Frank Maguire
VP of Insights, Strategy & Sustainability
Advertisers invest billions of dollars per year on banner ads but the “banner blindness” problem has only worsened since the appearance and delivery of banners has hardly changed in decades.

Our team at Sharethrough set out to study consumer behaviors as they browse and scroll through the internet to understand if and what could be done to banner ads to improve their performance and decrease banner blindness. This research led to a first-to-market product that automatically improves the performance of banner ads.

Eye-Tracking Studies Hint at A Potential Solution

Despite the massive growth of ad spend in highly publicized categories like video, social, native and CTV, advertisers still spent an estimated $46 Billion on banners in 2021, which is 30% growth since 2020 and 22% of overall digital ad spend (eMarketer). Yet numerous eye-tracking studies show people do not look at the banners, leading to inefficient or wasted investments.

However, those same eye-tracking studies, including one we conducted in 2013 with IPG Media Labs, confirmed that consumers focus on scanning headlines while scrolling through a site. This study ultimately led to the development of native ads that deliver better performance because they fit in with a headline.

Sharethrough’s eye-tracking study show consumers focus on scanning headlines while scrolling through a site.

So we wondered if the same logic would apply to banners. That is, if we added a headline to banners that matches the aesthetic of the site would it improve attention, boost message comprehension and improve the ad performance?

Testing Banners with Headlines

To test the impact on awareness and message comprehension, we tested multiple banners on 400 consumers as they scroll through content sites and broke them out into equal control and exposed groups. Control groups saw standard banners and exposed groups saw the same banners but with a headline that matched the look of the site. The headlines used the same exact text as the banner text to verify if people were more likely to read the same text as a headline.

A comparison between a banner ad without a headline and a banner ad enhanced by Sharethrough with a headline that matches the look of the site.

At the end of the browsing session, we asked the participants simple comprehension questions. Like if they saw an ad for the "top SUV of the year", and if they comprehended the messaging. And to measure awareness, we asked if they remembered which brand advertised.

Comprehension Improves by 2.5x

The improvement was stunning. People were 2.5x more likely to comprehend the message of the ad when we added a headline underneath the banner.

Sharethrough’s Enhanced Banners improve comprehension by 2.5x more than the standard banner ad with no headline.

And they were 17% more likely to remember the advertised brand.

Enhanced Banners Launch and Improve CTR by 7X

After these results, we decided to officially launch the product called “Enhanced Banners” that automatically adds either a default or customized headline to banners running on the Sharethrough Exchange. Since our mission is to improve performance of all ads, we do it for free without any additional CPM markup.  

To date, Enhanced Banners with default headlines are delivering a CTR average of 0.24%, which is 3X higher than industry average but Enhanced Banners with headlines that simply match the copy of the banner are delivering a CTR of 0.62%, which is 7X higher than industry average.

Simply Target Sharethrough in Any DSP

Applying headlines to banner ads can grab a user’s attention, increase their message comprehension and motivate them towards action, improving brand awareness and performance of display ad campaigns.

Start adding headlines to banners ads and improve the performance of your ad campaigns. Simply target Sharethrough with your banners in any DSP and we can automatically add headlines to your banner ads using approved brand copy, or you can send us the approved copy and we'll add the headlines for you.

Contact us for more information or if you have any questions.

To view the free infographic, fill the form below.

Advertisers invest billions of dollars per year on banner ads but the “banner blindness” problem has only worsened since the appearance and delivery of banners has hardly changed in decades.

Our team at Sharethrough set out to study consumer behaviors as they browse and scroll through the internet to understand if and what could be done to banner ads to improve their performance and decrease banner blindness. This research led to a first-to-market product that automatically improves the performance of banner ads.

Eye-Tracking Studies Hint at A Potential Solution

Despite the massive growth of ad spend in highly publicized categories like video, social, native and CTV, advertisers still spent an estimated $46 Billion on banners in 2021, which is 30% growth since 2020 and 22% of overall digital ad spend (eMarketer). Yet numerous eye-tracking studies show people do not look at the banners, leading to inefficient or wasted investments.

However, those same eye-tracking studies, including one we conducted in 2013 with IPG Media Labs, confirmed that consumers focus on scanning headlines while scrolling through a site. This study ultimately led to the development of native ads that deliver better performance because they fit in with a headline.

Sharethrough’s eye-tracking study show consumers focus on scanning headlines while scrolling through a site.

So we wondered if the same logic would apply to banners. That is, if we added a headline to banners that matches the aesthetic of the site would it improve attention, boost message comprehension and improve the ad performance?

Testing Banners with Headlines

To test the impact on awareness and message comprehension, we tested multiple banners on 400 consumers as they scroll through content sites and broke them out into equal control and exposed groups. Control groups saw standard banners and exposed groups saw the same banners but with a headline that matched the look of the site. The headlines used the same exact text as the banner text to verify if people were more likely to read the same text as a headline.

A comparison between a banner ad without a headline and a banner ad enhanced by Sharethrough with a headline that matches the look of the site.

At the end of the browsing session, we asked the participants simple comprehension questions. Like if they saw an ad for the "top SUV of the year", and if they comprehended the messaging. And to measure awareness, we asked if they remembered which brand advertised.

Comprehension Improves by 2.5x

The improvement was stunning. People were 2.5x more likely to comprehend the message of the ad when we added a headline underneath the banner.

Sharethrough’s Enhanced Banners improve comprehension by 2.5x more than the standard banner ad with no headline.

And they were 17% more likely to remember the advertised brand.

Enhanced Banners Launch and Improve CTR by 7X

After these results, we decided to officially launch the product called “Enhanced Banners” that automatically adds either a default or customized headline to banners running on the Sharethrough Exchange. Since our mission is to improve performance of all ads, we do it for free without any additional CPM markup.  

To date, Enhanced Banners with default headlines are delivering a CTR average of 0.24%, which is 3X higher than industry average but Enhanced Banners with headlines that simply match the copy of the banner are delivering a CTR of 0.62%, which is 7X higher than industry average.

Simply Target Sharethrough in Any DSP

Applying headlines to banner ads can grab a user’s attention, increase their message comprehension and motivate them towards action, improving brand awareness and performance of display ad campaigns.

Start adding headlines to banners ads and improve the performance of your ad campaigns. Simply target Sharethrough with your banners in any DSP and we can automatically add headlines to your banner ads using approved brand copy, or you can send us the approved copy and we'll add the headlines for you.

Contact us for more information or if you have any questions.

No items found.
About Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech—

Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech is a short 3-minute podcast exploring the news in the digital advertising industry. Ad tech is a fast-growing industry with many updates happening daily. As it can be hard for most to keep up with the latest news, the Sharethrough team wanted to create an audio series compiling notable mentions each week.

Advertisers invest billions of dollars per year on banner ads but the “banner blindness” problem has only worsened since the appearance and delivery of banners has hardly changed in decades.

Our team at Sharethrough set out to study consumer behaviors as they browse and scroll through the internet to understand if and what could be done to banner ads to improve their performance and decrease banner blindness. This research led to a first-to-market product that automatically improves the performance of banner ads.

Eye-Tracking Studies Hint at A Potential Solution

Despite the massive growth of ad spend in highly publicized categories like video, social, native and CTV, advertisers still spent an estimated $46 Billion on banners in 2021, which is 30% growth since 2020 and 22% of overall digital ad spend (eMarketer). Yet numerous eye-tracking studies show people do not look at the banners, leading to inefficient or wasted investments.

However, those same eye-tracking studies, including one we conducted in 2013 with IPG Media Labs, confirmed that consumers focus on scanning headlines while scrolling through a site. This study ultimately led to the development of native ads that deliver better performance because they fit in with a headline.

Sharethrough’s eye-tracking study show consumers focus on scanning headlines while scrolling through a site.

So we wondered if the same logic would apply to banners. That is, if we added a headline to banners that matches the aesthetic of the site would it improve attention, boost message comprehension and improve the ad performance?

Testing Banners with Headlines

To test the impact on awareness and message comprehension, we tested multiple banners on 400 consumers as they scroll through content sites and broke them out into equal control and exposed groups. Control groups saw standard banners and exposed groups saw the same banners but with a headline that matched the look of the site. The headlines used the same exact text as the banner text to verify if people were more likely to read the same text as a headline.

A comparison between a banner ad without a headline and a banner ad enhanced by Sharethrough with a headline that matches the look of the site.

At the end of the browsing session, we asked the participants simple comprehension questions. Like if they saw an ad for the "top SUV of the year", and if they comprehended the messaging. And to measure awareness, we asked if they remembered which brand advertised.

Comprehension Improves by 2.5x

The improvement was stunning. People were 2.5x more likely to comprehend the message of the ad when we added a headline underneath the banner.

Sharethrough’s Enhanced Banners improve comprehension by 2.5x more than the standard banner ad with no headline.

And they were 17% more likely to remember the advertised brand.

Enhanced Banners Launch and Improve CTR by 7X

After these results, we decided to officially launch the product called “Enhanced Banners” that automatically adds either a default or customized headline to banners running on the Sharethrough Exchange. Since our mission is to improve performance of all ads, we do it for free without any additional CPM markup.  

To date, Enhanced Banners with default headlines are delivering a CTR average of 0.24%, which is 3X higher than industry average but Enhanced Banners with headlines that simply match the copy of the banner are delivering a CTR of 0.62%, which is 7X higher than industry average.

Simply Target Sharethrough in Any DSP

Applying headlines to banner ads can grab a user’s attention, increase their message comprehension and motivate them towards action, improving brand awareness and performance of display ad campaigns.

Start adding headlines to banners ads and improve the performance of your ad campaigns. Simply target Sharethrough with your banners in any DSP and we can automatically add headlines to your banner ads using approved brand copy, or you can send us the approved copy and we'll add the headlines for you.

Contact us for more information or if you have any questions.

About Calibrate—

Founded in 2015, Calibrate is a yearly conference for new engineering managers hosted by seasoned engineering managers. The experience level of the speakers ranges from newcomers all the way through senior engineering leaders with over twenty years of experience in the field. Each speaker is greatly concerned about the craft of engineering management. Organized and hosted by Sharethrough, it was conducted yearly in September, from 2015-2019 in San Francisco, California.

Stay Up-to-Date—

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive cutting-edge digital advertising insights, including our weekly Behind Headlines episodes, delivered right to your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Listen to Next—
3:00
November 19, 2021
Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech — Secrecy & Augmented Reality
This week in Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech we’re chatting about secret ad buyers, a new partnership, and augmented reality.
3:00
November 12, 2021
Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech — Connected TVs & Digital Publishers
This week in Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech we’re talking about Connected TV ads and print publishers going digital.
3:00
November 5, 2021
Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech — Metaverses & Social TV
This week in Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech we’re chatting about a new metaverse entry, social platforms on TV, and ad experiences.
Watch Next—
3:00
July 2, 2021
Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech — Delayed Cookies & Investments
This week in Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech we’re talking about the delay in the depreciation of third-party cookies & news on IPOs.
3:00
June 25, 2021
Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech — Power Plays & Privacy
This week in Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech we’re taking a look at the role of competition and key player’s growing dominance.
3:00
June 18 2021
Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech — Lawsuits & Set Backs In Addressability
This week in Behind Headlines: 180 Seconds in Ad Tech we’re talking about the rise in privacy and addressability, from lawsuits to setbacks.
Frank Maguire
VP of Insights, Strategy & Sustainability

About the Author

Frank has spent over a decade at Sharethrough conducting research to better understand how humans respond to advertising to help brands and agencies adapt their unique advertising challenges to ever-evolving media consumption behaviors. In order to accelerate sustainability initiatives at Sharethrough and across the advertising industry, he recently completed his “Sustainability in Business” certification from Harvard Business School. He has also led multiple sustainability initiatives, including helping to launch the ad industry’s first Green Media Product “GreenPMPs,” hosting the advertising industry’s first Green Media Summit and speaking at Climate Week NYC. He is a digital advertising industry veteran, beginning his career working for clients including Nestle, Pfizer and Wyndham on the agency side and then opening up and growing Sharethrough’s East Coast headquarters in NYC.

More from this author
Notification Image

Sharethrough & Equativ are Merging!

Together, we form one of the largest independent ad platforms and marketplaces worldwide.

Learn More →